3 hours ago
3
In a succession battle worthy of the HBO drama the family helped inspire, months of intense negotiations between the warring family members ensued. It was an acrimonious process that saw the opposing factions resort to communicating through lawyers.
Critical to the conflict was politics.
James (left), Elisabeth, Rupert and Lachlan Murdoch in happier times.Credit: Getty Images
Lachlan, the heir apparent who took over the day-to-day running of the Murdoch businesses in 2023, is closely aligned with his father, whereas James, Elisabeth and Prudence Murdoch are viewed as more liberal.
For Rupert, securing the right-wing stance of his media assets was crucial. In an email released during the Nevada trial, he wrote: “Fox and our papers are the only faintly conservative voices against the monolithic liberal media. I believe maintaining this is vital to the future of the English-speaking world.”
Loading
The eventual solution was complicated. Through the previous family trust, Rupert held a 40 per cent voting stake in both News Corp and Fox. This will be replaced by a new trust controlled by Lachlan, but its stakes in the two companies have been diluted to 33 per cent and 36 per cent, respectively.
News Corp and Fox have mandated Morgan Stanley to sell shares worth about $US1.4 billion on behalf of the three children leaving the trust. Prudence, Elisabeth and James will receive $US1.1 billion each in return for their stakes.
“I am not surprised that the siblings went for the money,” says one former Murdoch executive. “There is always a cheque that will resolve these disputes.”
However, the exact details of the complex arrangement remain murky. It is not yet known who has bought up the shares in News Corp and Fox – described by analyst Claire Enders as an “attractive investment with some transparency” – though it is thought to include Australian institutional investors and pension funds.
Possible Middle Eastern involvement
Murdoch has raised further funding in the form of a $US1 billion loan. While this is believed to have been provided by JPMorgan, it is not clear which fund has been used or where the money originates.
Saudi billionaire Prince Alwaleed bin Talal was a long-time investor who stood by the family when the News of the World phone hacking scandal erupted in 2011.Credit: AP
This opacity raises the possibility of Middle Eastern involvement, especially given Murdoch’s previous ties with wealthy Arab individuals. Prince Alwaleed bin Talal, a Saudi Arabian billionaire, was a long-time investor who stood by the family when the News of the World phone hacking scandal erupted in 2011.
Any involvement by sovereign wealth funds would ring alarm bells in the wake of new laws banning the ownership of British newspapers by foreign states.
The laws, introduced this year in response to the failed takeover of The Telegraph by UAE-backed fund RedBird IMI, cap ownership by foreign states at 15 per cent. A holding of 5 per cent or more requires the investor to notify the Secretary of State, while any debt arrangement may be scrutinised if it is deemed to convey influence over the title.
Murdoch’s News UK has been a vocal opponent of the laws and lobbied vocally to raise the threshold of the ownership cap, which was initially proposed at 5 per cent.
Loading
In response to a government consultation earlier this year, it said a 15 per cent cap “would provide clarity for all stakeholders and avoid unduly jeopardising continued investment in the UK’s media and newspaper industry whilst appropriately protecting against foreign state influence”.
It is not thought that News UK has been required to notify ministers of any foreign state involvement. A source familiar with the transaction said there was no third-party involvement in the loan. News Corp declined to comment on the source of the funding.
Whatever the source of the money, Murdoch’s supporters argue that the deal removes a major uncertainty that was hanging over his empire.
“It shows that our strategy will be consistent. It’s clear, and it’s very sustainable,” Lachlan said. “We can be very focused on returning capital to investors, driving our profitability and, really importantly, investing in our core brands and especially in our great journalism.”
Nevertheless, the mystery investment leaves some questions over the future direction of Murdoch’s empire unanswered.
The new trust guarantees Lachlan’s control until at least 2050. Many believe, however, that Murdoch’s death will be the real game-changer.
“The future of the empire is as it is until Mr Murdoch leaves this Earth,” says Enders. “I think it’s really unlikely that there’s going to be any change in the assets while he’s alive.”
Further down the line, more change could be afoot. Lachlan earlier this year launched a now-aborted takeover bid for Rightmove through REA, the Australian real estate group that has proved to be his savviest investment. The newly crowned mogul could look at further dealmaking to diversify the group away from its media assets.
More controversially, he may shun sentimentality and decide to sell off the group’s loss-making Australian newspapers. Enders describes Lachlan as “extremely pragmatic”.
Yet the succession process has diluted Lachlan’s grip on the empire. The future role played by Chloe and Grace, Rupert’s youngest children from his marriage to Wendi Deng, who are also beneficiaries of the new trust, is another unknown.
Meanwhile, the Murdochs have already faced opposition from investors. Aside from the shareholder revolt over the proposed merger between News Corp and Fox, activist Starboard Value has attempted to break the family’s grip by abolishing a dual-class share structure. It has also pushed for a spin-off of REA.
Loading
So while the deal appears to have secured the future of the Murdoch empire for the coming decades, an atmosphere of interregnum still reigns. The surprise decision by David Dinsmore, the former editor of The Sun and long-serving Murdoch lieutenant, to quit for a communications role in No 10 – a move accompanied by a bruising pay cut – has been viewed by many as a symptom of this uncertainty.
Rupert Murdoch’s ability to broker a deal with his feuding family is likely to be viewed as one of the final – and most crucial – victories for the media mogul. But the future of his empire remains far from guaranteed.
The Business Briefing newsletter delivers major stories, exclusive coverage and expert opinion. Sign up to get it every weekday morning.
